
Topic RSS
3:57 pm
1 December, 2011
OfflineHey guys!
So I was in the studio the other day and there was this one melody line that I kept messing up! I kept singing it a half step up when I was suppose to be singing it a half step down. Now, I love recording in the studio but it got me thinking that if I were to sing the song live then that line wouldn't have even mattered. When you sing live you give a performance which really exposes your soul. You sing how your heart tells you to sing and most importantly you feel the music and the energy when you perform on stage. However, in the studio I feel singing is so regimented and we always want to get it perfect… no one is perfect! Now a days our ears are use to hearing perfection because of auto tune and our technology in the recording studio. Everyone on the radio sounds so clear and so perfect and so amazing… and not to say they are not amazing, but sounding flawless is how our ears are now programmed to hear music. Anyways, I wanted to know what you guys prefer. Singing live or singing in the studio?
autotune is great
anyway, if you think about choral parts. It's impossible that all singers sing perfectly, so there are ones singing up and ones singing down and the overall sound is amazing. Old centuries composers didn't have autotune and their works were masterpieces.
I like to sing whenever I can, and I've been with a band. I'm not a singer, just like to have all the artistic experiences I can. I think singing live is the best one, I can say.
exposing the soul is the heart and core of singing, i would suggest
put things in the studio or booth you feel that would help you channel that soul
while u blend the practice of regiment at the same time just my opinion.
it works for me!
3:00 pm
the music i record i never use true tone for the vocals, – as long as its close to being in key its fine – plus i recon the raw sound is much better after all – if it was all true toned then it would merge the very talented with the norm and be very boring…. nothing like hearing a good singer live!
check out my solo work @ https://www.facebook.com/pages/All-Are-None/195714817156290
3:13 pm
I imagine there are a few folks who feel as I do when it comes to hearing my recorded voice. We don't like to hear it. Rather like those actors who don't care to see themselves on screen. To me it's fantasy versus reality. In my body, my voice resonates so beautifully and it's a joy to step outside oneself and hear it. Then I hear it recorded and I just want to duck and cover. I hear every little thing and I think OMG that's what I really sound like? It's discouraging, I agree. Especially when it's a live recording and no opportunity to punch back in. The beauty of live performance on the other hand is that it is fleeting, with no rewind, and combined with all the other elements that go along with a live performance, location, ambiance, the other players, the energy of the audience, etc, a rough spot goes by scarily noticed because it all flows together so seamlessly. Auto tune is for those folks who can't sing consistently in tune OR who are relying on looks rather than substance… i.e. the Brittany Spears of the world whose vocals are so electronically augmented one can scarecly distinguish what is really her and what isn't. So many of the artists of today are being manufactured to appeal to the pop culture based mostly on appearance rather than capabilities. Guess that's why they build hugh shows, with back-up dancers to divert attention away from lack luster vocals. Just sayin'…
guest said
the music i record i never use true tone for the vocals, – as long as its close to being in key its fine – plus i recon the raw sound is much better after all – if it was all true toned then it would merge the very talented with the norm and be very boring…. nothing like hearing a good singer live!
check out my solo work @ https://www.facebook.com/pages/All-Are-None/195714817156290![]()
Mark, welcome in the forum first of all
, I really appreciated "all i see in you". The other tracks are not exactly my genre, but I can recognize well done music and you are for sure a talent!
guest said
I imagine there are a few folks who feel as I do when it comes to hearing my recorded voice. We don't like to hear it. Rather like those actors who don't care to see themselves on screen. To me it's fantasy versus reality. In my body, my voice resonates so beautifully and it's a joy to step outside oneself and hear it. Then I hear it recorded and I just want to duck and cover. I hear every little thing and I think OMG that's what I really sound like?
You know what I think? our voice is totally different when we hear it recorded. It's normal, just focus on the tone and performance. After you hear it for a while, you'll like it
yeah, our voice is different when recorded (or maybe we hear it different but it's the same for anyone else)
12:40 pm
To be honest I am a big enemy of auto-tune. I can always tell when it has been used in recordings and I can't help but feel disgust at how unnatural it feels. Also I feel that just like soccer players get paid millions to be superhuman, so should a famous singer be able to perform at the very least correctly. Do not get me wrong, I am all for technology and I do not want to troll this forum, but auto-tune is like using steroids for muscle building, and it should only be used as a premeditated effect, or when there is really no other choice (i.e. the bad fragment cannot be re-recorded). One must remember subtlety is your ally in studio, as opposed to live where you often need power and feel.
Having said that, next time you see yourself missing a note often in studio, ask them to regulate the reverb on your monitor (headphones) so that you can get a good enough feedback and can comfortably sing in tune. The super-muffled studio booths for singers offer less echo than usual and it can be hard to sing at ease.
Other reasons affecting a part where you are out of tune might be vocalization: try to shape your mouth with precision in a more exaggerated way than usual.
I hope I did not sound patronizing since I just want to be helpful.
Keep it up! ![]()
hey Alex
nice to read you!
i don't like autotune, too. it's too easy for a new singer to perform correctly these days, with all the technology we have, but very few singers really can sing without a technological help.
Only these should be recognized.
11:57 am
27 February, 2012
OfflineI THINK IT CAN GO EITHER WAY…as long as YOU feel it. W.T.F.E. LOL! But, some of my best takes in the studio contain"mistakes" that actually make the track, and I will NOT DARE use auto tune…. WHY? BECAUSE I'M GOOD…LOL. But as an aside, the other day I was using youtube to find THE DOORS songs and that guy f-ing AMAZING… every LIVE song I heard was exactly like the ones I heard on the album…. EVERY SONG & EVERY NOTE. I have an ear for it plus, I know all these songs by heart, but music is expression & sometimes it's different, that just makes it creative & well… ART!
Most Users Ever Online: 115
Currently Online:
10 Guest(s)
Currently Browsing this Page:
1 Guest(s)
Top Posters:
ianguitar: 78
Debby: 60
Pami: 48
KingHawley: 46
kaylee: 43
dustind: 43
Flynn: 43
layla: 39
phoenixlux: 37
useTheForce: 33
Member Stats:
Guest Posters: 15
Members: 12545
Moderators: 25
Admins: 1
Forum Stats:
Groups: 9
Forums: 31
Topics: 369
Posts: 1341
Newest Members: adamadan888, SoutreyCasper, FettiLootch, 3rg0, maryzhao, rdr747, jackyr, ParodyWriter, peter popalo, tabigo
Moderators: idbeholda (5), Peter G Mackie (6), bvanevery (202), ntfs (12), ntapia (21), wsinclair (1), NoelRamos (29), songbirdinc (0), KillingAriella (11), PabloDePacas (1), sheldon_music (7), Michael Rien (2), ChrisArmesMusic (0), Sethburg (0), officialmeelis (4), bl (13), TriangleX (21), wynline (0), Cynthia Janes (10), Lisadonna (8), lisacpollockmusic (0), MelissaSalandra (5), Ashley Christine (0), coolandy692000 (3), kdiggy (19)
Administrators: Manuel Marino (165)






Log In
Register
Members
Home
Add Reply
Add Topic


Quote





